<aside> ๐ ๏ธ Six revisions, one for each problem teams send back most: a weak opening, unreadable captions, unclear product value, excessive motion, poor pacing and an abrupt CTA. Each one ran P28 (Revision director) on an earlier draft of a worked sequence: the original direction, the diagnosis, the revised specification, what stays and a reading check.
</aside>
| # | Problem | Sequence | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A weak opening | Pennyport | Open |
| 2 | Unreadable captions | Stretchbreak | Overlay |
| 3 | Unclear product value | Fridgefolk | Show |
| 4 | Excessive motion | Ironvale Siege | Open |
| 5 | Poor pacing | Tidewords | Show |
| 6 | An abrupt CTA | Bloomstack | Close |
Original direction. Scene 1 fades the logo in from black over 1.5 seconds. The line under it reads "Smarter money starts here." The app screen first appears at 4 seconds.
Diagnosis. Frame one is black, so nothing reads on mute. A general money promise says nothing about the viewer's moment. The problem the app solves does not appear until second four.
Revised specification.
| Scene | Time (s) | Copy | Motion |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Hook | 0.0 to 2.2 | Payday was 9 days ago. | Word by word, rise 0.4 s each, 0.12 s apart, ease out cubic. "9 days" in mint. |
| 2 Turn | 2.2 to 4.6 | Where did it all go? | Push up 0.4 s, ease in out cubic. Line enters whole. |
| Logo | 12.0 to 15.0 | Pennyport | Moves to the end card only. |
What stays. The demo, the call to action and the end card. Total length 15 seconds.
Reading check. Hook: 5 words, needs 2.0 s, holds 2.2 s. Turn: 5 words, needs 2.0 s, holds 2.4 s.
Original direction. White captions with no box sit in the bottom 10 percent of the 9:16 frame. Three words show at a time, each group for 0.7 seconds.
Diagnosis. The bottom of a 9:16 frame sits under the platform's caption bar and buttons. White text with no box disappears on a bright desk. Groups of 0.7 seconds break the sentence and fall below the 1.2 second floor.
Revised specification.
| Scene | Time (s) | Copy | Motion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caption style | all | Dark box at 75% opacity, white bold type | Type at 6% of the safe width. One line where possible, two at most. |
| Position | all | Lower middle of the safe box | Above the bottom 25% margin, clear of the right 14% button column. |
| Line 1 | 2.5 to 6.0 | I take four minutes between calls. | Whole sentence. Words fade in with speech, 0.1 s apart. Holds 3.5 s. |
What stays. Creator footage, the routine card, the timer card and the end card.