https://localgovernmentutopia.com/long-reads/classic-paper-managing-government-and-governing-management-henry-mintzberg/

https://hbr.org/1996/05/managing-government-governing-management

Mintzberg contests the idea that government must become more like business. A balanced society needs four forms of ownership: private, state, cooperative and non-owned. People relate to government in four roles, as customer, client, citizen and subject, and only the first fits business logic well. "Capital-M Management", the ideology of MBA programmes and management books, rests on three assumptions that collapse in most government work. Government uses five organising models, and no one of them is best. But the normative model, which runs on values rather than targets, is the one government can't work without.

Business is not all good and government is not all bad. Each sector can learn from the others. Society needs "proud, not emasculated" government. Above all, the sectors need balance.

Key take away:

In this paper Mintzberg covers four broad topics relevant to local government:

  1. Private, public, cooperative and non-owned organisations.
  2. The roles of people in society as customer, client, citizen and subject.
  3. The management myths that activities can be isolated, performance can be fully evaluated using objective measures, and activities can be entrusted to autonomous managers responsible for performance.
  4. The machine model, network model, performance-control model, virtual model and normative-control model available to organise government.

NOTES and Extracts

“In my view, we have confounded the whole relationship between business and government,”

There are four forms of ownership: