<aside>
๐งญ
Working page of the Claude orchestrator. Tracks implementation status, decisions Claude made on its own (with reasons), and open decisions that need a human. Repo: ~/PycharmProjects/ygo-tt-rogue. Plan followed: Tech Foundation Plan.
</aside>
โ Open decisions (need you)
Source: research report docs/research/licensing-and-terms.md. Recommended default in brackets.
- [x] Repo license: ygopro-core, CardScripts and Puzzles are AGPL-3.0; we link the core in-process, so engine/ and host/ are AGPL-bound anyway. [AGPL-3.0-or-later for the whole repo + THIRD_PARTY.md] :: yes lets do APGL โ done:
LICENSE (AGPL-3.0) + license field in every package
- [x] MIT carve-out for relay/ and protocol/? [no, for now] :: decide on your own
- [x] Source link in the UI (needed for AGPL ยง13 once a guest connects) [yes: client footer, About screen, host landing page] :: you decide
- [x] Card image source: YGOPRODeck is the only usable public CDN (20 req/s, "download once, don't hotlink"). The ProjectIgnis pics URL the PoC uses is private. [YGOPRODeck, cache once, pool cards only, throttled] :: you decide
- [x] Branding: Konami takedown risk grows with "Yu-Gi-Oh!" in the product name, images and monetisation. [no "Yu-Gi-Oh!" in the title, original card back, disclaimer, non-commercial] :: no name yet, lets keep the placeholder for now โ kept "Tag Duel"
- [x] Teacher data for the own policy model [API keys or local Qwen/DeepSeek only, never consumer plans]
- [x] Telemetry [opt-in, anonymous at source, 24 months raw retention, privacy notice] โ implemented with these defaults; upload endpoint still needed (nothing is sent until one is configured)
- [x] "Haiku 5.5" doesn't exist (Enemies & AI tier table). Current Haiku is
claude-haiku-4-5 (no effort parameter). [Minion = Haiku 4.5 without thinking, Minion+ = Haiku 4.5 with a thinking budget; Sonnet/Opus 5.5 as listed, "mid" = medium effort]
- [x] Default AI backend when nothing is configured [scripted bot, so nothing calls a paid model by accident]
- [x] Upgrade amounts: Big / Wise / Lesser [+500 ATK/DEF, Level +1, Level โ1] :: Upgrade amounts can be anything, as soon as its stats are raised it becomes big, raising twice doesnt make it Big Big, same for level โ done: each upgrade carries its own amount (content: Bonfire Big +300, shop and encounter Big +500, Wise/Lesser ยฑ1). The name gets each prefix once and the text shows the totals ("Big: +800 ATK/DEF"). Wise and Lesser add up to one net Level change; only the net direction's prefix shows. Old saves still load.
- [x] Can upgrades be negated (e.g. by Skill Drain)? [no]
- [x] Holy (no cost) scope: works cleanly on 74% of the 4,793 cards with costs. 476 cards would get unlimited free uses (e.g. Cannon Soldier). [Holy only for cards on an allow-list; repeatable self-costs get an added once-per-turn; no Holy where it changes nothing] :: leave it in even if 476 become broken, thats the fun of a roguelike. if too op we can tweak in the future โ done: the added once-per-turn is off, so those 476 cards are freely repeatable. The allow-list stays only for cards that technically break.
- [x] Does the Toon upgrade make the card a Toon monster (TYPE_TOON)? [no, it only gets the attack rules]
- [x] Cheat budget per tier ("Mini-Boss can cheat once" is in the design; the rest isn't). [Minion 0, Mini-Boss 1, Boss 2, Final Boss 3; cheats only in the boss's own Main Phase]
- [x] Who may cheat? Dialogue tables include cheat lines for every deck; the engine budgets are Minion 0 / Mini-Boss 1 / Boss 2 / Final Boss 3
- [ ] Which skill each boss has: Notion defines the mechanism (turn counter, predefined actions) but no per-boss skills. [being implemented: a generic default per tier with turn/LP triggers and a predefined action list (draw 1, destroy the strongest opposing monster, recover 1000 LP); replace with per-boss tables later]
- [x] Predefined vs freely generated cheats / Yugi cheating for all bosses? (Enemies & AI open questions) [scripted bot: predefined tables; LLM route: the LLM picks a structured action from the whitelist, validated by the host, budget per tier, all (mini-)bosses]