The fashionable PSI discourse wants government to be less bureaucratic, less "Weberian", more like Apple and shiny private companies (p. 9).
Kattel says that question is wrong. He traces three periods of PSI thinking: Schumpeterian, organisation-theory and "autochthonous". None of them explains how profound change actually happens in the public sector, because they borrow private-sector evolutionary ideas, like competition, imitation and first-mover advantage, that barely exist or aren't wanted in government (p. 14). He goes back to Tocqueville and Weber instead. Both were concerned with how authority is kept in a society of competing interests, through institutional and administrative change.
The key idea is that public-sector constraints are intrinsic. They are at once the thing being changed and the thing limiting change. So public-sector change doesn't unfold smoothly through competition. It moves in fits and starts, shaped by political, legal and administrative constraints, which Kattel calls "punctured" evolution. Tocqueville's example: judicial oversight constrained elected township officials, and that same constraint produced better services.
Summarizing above 150 years of discussion on conceptualizing public-sector innovations and innovations generally, we can draw the following conclusions: It can be argued that a recently emerging literature on social innovation tries to fi ll the gap in public-sector-innovation literature by looking at values and social relevance and thus moves the discussions towards issues of authority, trust, etc; see Bekkers et al. 2013 for an overview.
What would Max Weber Say about Public-Sector Innovation? From the oldest literature discussing public-sector innovations (Tocqueville, Weber):
In sum, looking at these two strands of older and recent literature on PSI, we can see that disproportionally large areas of public-sector activity in relations to innovations are under-researched in current PSI research. Max Weber