In Dostoyevsky's The Brothers Karamazov, a woman named Mrs. Khokhlakov visits an elder at a monastery. She's been watching him speak with some peasant women, and their faith moves her. But when she finally gets a chance to speak, she admits that her own faith is in trouble.

The elder asks whether she's having difficulty believing in God.

She says that what frightens her is death. "What if, after I've been a believer all my life, when I die it suddenly turns out that after life there's nothing at all, nothing but wild grass growing on my grave, as some writer put it. That's horrible! And how can I regain my faith?”

As a little girl, she believed without questioning. Now she wants to know how she can become convinced.

The elder says, “By acts of love, try to love your neighbors, love them, actively and unceasingly, and as you learn to love them more and more, you'll be more and more convinced of the existence of God and of the immortality of your soul, and if you achieve complete self-abnegation in your love for your fellow man, you will certainly gain faith, and then there will be no room in your soul for any doubt whatsoever. This has been tested. This is the true way."

Well, this sounds encouraging. Mrs. Khokhlakov loves humanity. In fact, she sometimes imagines giving up everything to become a nurse. She pictures herself caring for suffering people, washing their wounds. In those moments, she feels capable of almost anything.

But then she thinks about the patients.

"Yes, but how long do you think I should live such a life?" Mrs. Khokhlakov said, heatedly, an almost hysterical note creeping into her voice. "That's the crucial point! Yes, that's the question that torments me most. I close my eyes, and I ask myself: 'How long do you think you could endure that life? What if a patient, whose sores you were cleaning, instead of being grateful to you, tormented you with his whim and had no appreciation whatsoever for your services to mankind, talked rudely to you, or complained about you to your superiors, as people who are in pain so often do? What would happen then? Would you go on loving him or not?' And I must tell you that, to my own dismay, I have come to this conclusion: if anything could dampen my active love for mankind, it is ingratitude. In other words, I'm willing to work if I'm paid for it, but I want to be paid at once. I mean, I want to be praised and paid for love with love. Otherwise, I'm quite incapable of loving anyone."

Well, at least she's honest, right? In my better moments, I like to think I'm capable of doing something heroic for humanity. You know, something big, compelling, world- and life-changing. Coming up, I wanted to be Martin Luther King or Oscar Romero, martyrdom notwithstanding.

But then I spend an afternoon with someone who needs help but doesn't express gratitude for the time and energy I've spent, and it doesn't take long for me to suddenly remember other places I need to be.

It's not a very flattering image of me, I'll admit. But I find it seems so much more satisfying to imagine theoretical people I might help than the often unpleasant person in front of me.

Loving God feels manageable when we get to control what that love looks like. We've got our favorite pew, hymns we like, and worship language we prefer. The whole arrangement seems pretty doable in the abstract. But you start throwing unruly, extremely needy, or ungrateful people into the mix and things get complicated quickly.

Mrs. Khokhlakov comes to the monastery with questions about how she can become more certain of her salvation. In response, the elder tells her to give some thought to how she loves the person in front of her.

That feels like an extraordinarily prickly and uncomfortable place to begin a conversation about faith.

But apparently, that's exactly where Jesus wants to land in our Gospel this morning.

What do I mean?

Well, after going rounds with the Sadducees over the subject of the resurrection, the Pharisees jump into the theological scrum. "Teacher, which commandment in the Law is the greatest?"

Jesus reaches back to Deuteronomy: "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.' This is the greatest and first commandment."

Which is a pretty good place to start, all things being equal.

But Jesus isn't content to stop there, which is a bit presumptuous because they asked him to name only the greatest. But Jesus is nothing if not self-directed. As is his custom, he does what he wants. And in this case, what Jesus wants is to link two commandments together so closely that there's no daylight between them.